TORONTO — Connor McDavid and Auston Matthews were prominently featured on the marquee coming into Saturday.
Two superstars revolutionizing their sport prepare for a thrilling matchup.
Instead, a few of Toronto’s depth players grabbed center stage.
Bobby McMann scored twice as part of a three-point night, and Pontus Holmberg added two goals as the Maple Leafs built a big lead before some nervous moments late in a 6-3 victory over Connor McDavid’s Edmonton Oilers.
“Team effort,” said McMann, who has gone from healthy scratch to vital roster piece in less than a month. “Many guys contributed to that. There’s a reason we get chances, odd-man rushes, and plays around the goal.
“Guys around us are working hard.”
For Toronto (40-20-9), William Nylander scored and set up another before Matthews scored his NHL-leading 58th goal into an empty net while also assisting.
John Tavares and Timothy Liljegren both contributed two assists. Ilya Samsonov made 31 saves before leaving with an injury late in the game. Martin Jones stopped five shots on mop-up duty.
“Our guys just competed hard,” stated Leafs head coach Sheldon Keefe, adding that Samsonov should be fine. “We played with lots of attitude.”
Former Leafs forwards Zach Hyman, Corey Perry, and Leon Draisaitl answered for Edmonton (42-22-4), which was 9-1-2 in its previous 12 games. McDavid got three assists, giving him 89 for the season, while Evan Bouchard added
“Weird game,” Draisaitl said. “They probably capitalized on every single one of their chances, and we gave up a little too much the first 40 (minutes).”
The talk coming into Saturday’s showcase was dominated by McDavid and Matthews’ pursuit of jaw-dropping milestones, along with Hyman sitting two goals short of 50.
McDavid is looking to become just the fourth different NHLer — and the first since Wayne Gretzky in 1990-91 — to hit 100 assists in a season, while Matthews could become the first to score 70 times since 1992-93s.
The Leafs’ supporting cast, however, largely flipped the script down a handful of sick and injured regulars.
“They loaded up their first line,” said Toronto’s Jake McCabe, who along with fellow defenceman Joel Edmundson was a nasty, physical presence all night. “We want our depth to carry us through and show that we have better depth.
“Ended up being the difference.”
After the Leafs killed off an early penalty, McMann opened the scoring with his 12th goal of 2023-24 at 4:17 of the first period before Nylander added his 39th on a slick power-play deflection at 18:14.
Samsonov made a hockey-card worthy windmill glove save off a blast by Edmonton defenceman Brett Kulak early in the second.
Holmberg scored his fifth at 8:02 for a 3-0 advantage after Matthews won a race and Max Domi unselfishly found the forward for a wide-open net.
The Swede added his second of the night 3:02 later on a 3-on-1 after the Leafs killed another penalty.
“Both guys were terrific,” Keefe said of McMann and Holmberg. “We had great efforts from everybody.”
Samsonov robbed Hyman, who never had more than 21 goals in his five seasons with Toronto before departing in free agency, of his 49th goal later in the period.
McMann then wired his 13th upstairs at 15:46 for a 5-0 lead through 40 minutes.
“That was pretty sweet,” said the native of Wainwright, Alta. “Playing against Edmonton, watching them growing up and the quality team that is, it was a special one.”
McMann hadn’t checked his phone before speaking with reporters, but expected some messages from back home.
“I hope they’re happy for me and not too worried about the Oilers losing,” the 27-year-old said with a smile. “But we’ll see.”
Hyman got that 49th goal on a power play 4:59 into the third and Perry added his 10th on another man advantage at 8:32.
Draisaitl scored his 36th with 3:39 left and Pickard on the bench for an extra attacker on the sequence that saw Samsonov get hurt.
The Oilers continued to press, with Ryan Nugent-Hopkins hitting the post on Jones, but Toronto held on before Matthews iced it with his first empty-net goal of the season on a night where McMann and Holmberg stole the superstar thunder.
“It’s a fun atmosphere to play in and a great game to play in,” Tavares said. “It’s great to see.
“Especially on this stage.”
MISSING LEAFS
Toronto was minus injured forwards Mitch Marner (high ankle sprain) and Calle Jarnkrok (hand), while winger Tyler Bertuzzi and defenceman Ilya Lyubushkin both missed out with an illness.
T.J. Brodie was a healthy scratch for the second straight game as the team looks to give the usually dependable blueliner a mental reset.
